In many marine discussion forums the are heated debates going on about the usage of tablets as the primary MFD (Multi Function Display)/Navigation device. Questions like “Why is there not sonar and radar for iPad/Android tablets. And why should I pay $3000 for a 10” Chart Plotter from Garmin, Raymarine, Lowrance or Simrad when I have a 10” Table for less than $1000. Click to read more for our take on the issue!
Marine Weather Sealing
Ohh well.. First of all – most tablets are not really built for outside usage. They are not “Weather Sealed” – so moisture can enter into the device and can damage components.
That is especially true if you are in a salt water environment.The salt will corrode away at the internals in ANY electronics that are not weather sealed. So first – you need to buy a “weather proof” case for your tablet to seal it. Else you might end up having to buy a new tablet every single year – taking the cost of ownership to higher levels than a buying a “pure” marine display.
Then the other problem is screen reflections. Most tablets have screens that are not anti glare coated. That means you will have a lot of reflections on the display – making it hard to read. Remember that water is a very good reflector of sun-rays – so you do not only get direct reflections from the sun – you get all the reflections from the sea as well.
If you decide to add an anti glare shield to your tablet – then you get another problem. Any “layer” you add to your devices screen – WILL lower the brightness. Dependent on brand – the brightness might be lowered anywhere from 5-25%.
A Marine Chart plotter uses “industrial” high powered screens. Screen brightness is measured it NIT’s or cd(Candela)/m2 where 1 NIT = 1 cd/m2.
So what are the NIT ratings of different screens?
|Colour Calibrated Monitor for Publishing||120|
|Home PC LCD Monitor||200-300|
|Google Nexus 7 Tablet||400|
|iPad “3” Retina display||400|
|LCD/LED TV (Good quality)||600-1100|
|Panasonic CF19 2011 Toughbook (Notebook)||1000|
|Panasonic H2 Toughbook Tablet (2012)||Up to 6000 (Screen is really only 500 Nit but can use Sunlight to “amplify” brightness)|
|Marine MFD/Chart plotter (after anti-glare treatment)||800-1600|
So as you can see from the above the light coming out of a Marine specific device is a LOT more than what you get from you tablets. And that is essential for outdoor viewing – especially in sunlight – direct or reflected.
Above is a picture of a Google Nexus 7 – and an iPad 3 Retina – both with brightness on full blast. Then compare it to the Raymarine MFD. As you can see the Raymarine C97 display looks MUCH better in the afternoon sunlight. And notice the reflections. Almost none on the dedicated Marine Display – but a LOT on both the iPad and the Nexus 7.
Products like the Panasonic Toughbook H2 tablet might be worth looking at – but then you are at prices close to or higher than most 10” Marine MFD/Chart Plotters anyway. And if you need to “Dock” it with a permanent mount solution you do end up with a quite ugly setup No flush mounts available.
Using Tablets as primary navigation device – conclusion
So in short – is a tablet a suitable replacement for a primary dedicated marine display? No not at the moment. Once we can get tablets with 1000+ NIT screens and full weather sealing it will be a great idea. But having a tablet as a Backup device is a great idea.
And it is quite nice to be able to sit in the cabin and plan your route on the Marine MFD/Chart Plotter via “Remote Control” from a Tablet as you now can with Raymarine and Simrad. Or sit in the back fishing – while keeping an eye on your fish-finder You still have to squint a bit to see the display – but better than no fish-finder view at all.
I do not doubt there will be Tablet Sonar’s and Radars available. Or at least “interfaces” so you can view and control sonar & radar from your Tablet via Simrad Go-Free for example. But I would not chose any current “tablets’ as my primary “Navigation” display any time soon.
[…] But iDevices are NOT ready to be main navigation equipment unless you have adequate shade since iDevices displays are not really bright enough to use outside on the water unless you use it in a cabin. If you have a cabin – you […]
[…] right and the link below has a great write-up on it. Ipad-Android tablets on boats a good idea?/ I wonder if anti-glare screens can be added to the screens but does not take into account of the […]
[…] I can say about Orca is that I am impressed. I have not been a big fan of Tablets for main navigation before – but with Orca’s new display that – at least according to published specifications – can […]